Designer Shingles vs. Traditional- Which Look Is Right for Your North Hills Home?

Your roof isn’t just protection — it’s part of your home’s personality.
Whether you’re upgrading for curb appeal, resale value, or storm protection, choosing between designer shingles and traditional asphalt shingles is one of the most important decisions you’ll make.

So, what’s the real difference — and which one fits your North Hills home best? Let’s break it down.

Traditional Asphalt Shingles: Reliable, Affordable, and Classic

Cost-Effective: Great for homeowners on a budget — installation and materials are affordable.

  • Energy Efficient: Reflect sunlight to help manage summer cooling costs.
  • Easy to Replace or Repair: Individual shingles can be swapped out after storms or wear.
  • Typical Lifespan: Around 15–25.

Perfect for: First-time homeowners, budget-conscious remodels, or rental properties where cost-efficiency is key.

Designer (Architectural) Shingles: Style Meets Strength

Designer shingles — also known as architectural or dimensional shingles — take things up a notch in both durability and design.

  • Longer Lifespan: 30–50 years depending on maintenance and brand.
  • Premium Look: Mimic the look of slate, cedar shake, or tile — without the weight or cost.
  • Enhanced Durability: Thicker layers resist high winds, hail, and harsh Pittsburgh weather.
  • Noise Reduction: Their density can help quiet rain and wind.

Perfect for: Homeowners upgrading long-term properties or anyone wanting a standout curb appeal in upscale North Hills neighborhoods.

Choosing What’s Right for Your North Hills Home Roof

When deciding between designer and traditional shingles, consider:

  • Your home’s style: Colonial? Craftsman? Modern? Designer shingles can elevate your home’s architecture.
  • Your budget: Traditional shingles keep costs down, but designer options boost long-term value.
  • Pittsburgh’s weather: If your home faces strong winds, heavy snow, or direct sun, designer shingles offer extra protection.
  • How long you’ll stay: Staying for decades? Designer is worth it.

Perfect for: Homeowners upgrading long-term properties or anyone wanting a standout curb appeal in upscale North Hills neighborhoods.

Let C.L. Frey Construction Help You Decide

At C.L. Frey Construction, we’ve helped North Hills homeowners choose the perfect roofing style for decades — balancing style, strength, and budget.  Our team delivers quality craftsmanship that lasts through every Pittsburgh season.


Call today for a personalized roof consultation and estimate — we’ll help you pick the look that fits your home and your lifestyle.